eBay appears to block AI agents such as Meta's Muse, The Verge reports
eBay did not say whether it recently set new limits but said it has restricted agent access in some cases. Amazon blocked Muse in September, citing its terms of use.
Key takeaways
- The Verge reported on Nov. 10 that AI agents such as Meta's Muse seem to be shut out of eBay, based on a reader's account and its own tests.
- eBay declined to say directly whether it set new limits, but said it has restricted agent access in some cases, such as unauthorized scraping and training on its data.
- Meta declined to comment to The Verge; NextFish found no other outlet reporting the eBay block.
- Amazon blocked Muse in September, saying Meta gave no notice, the agent does not identify itself and it seems to keep customer login details; Meta had said earlier that Muse cannot see passwords or payment details.
- Uber and DoorDash figures reported by The Verge suggest few orders are placed through third-party agents so far.
eBay seems to have stopped AI agents, Meta's Muse among them, from browsing its marketplace, The Verge reported on Nov. 10. The report rests on one reader's account and on The Verge's own attempts to repeat it. eBay did not confirm a change, The Verge is the only outlet NextFish found reporting the eBay block, and NextFish has not independently verified it.
What did The Verge find?
According to The Verge, a reader had for several weeks used a Muse agent to compile a daily digest of watches for sale on sites including eBay, with links, prices, shipping details and notes on condition. Over the weekend, the reader said, Muse could no longer retrieve links or details from eBay and told him it was blocked. The Verge says it reproduced the problem with other searches, and that in some cases Muse pointed users to outside sites that mirrored eBay listings.
What does eBay say?
An eBay spokesperson, Sybille St. Arromand, declined to say directly whether eBay had recently placed new limits on AI agents, The Verge reports. In an emailed statement quoted by the outlet, she said eBay takes "a selective approach" to third-party access to its marketplace. She said eBay has limited agent access in some situations, giving unauthorized scraping and training on eBay's data as examples. She said eBay is in ongoing talks with potential partners and is evaluating ways third-party agents could help new customers find its inventory, with a focus on "preserving the trusted end-to-end experience that buyers and sellers expect." She also said AI is being built into eBay's own platform for discovery, personalisation and selling. Meta declined to comment, according to The Verge.
The Verge notes that eBay had already changed its user agreement to bar tools such as "buy-for-me agents" and "LLM-driven bots" that place orders without human review. Until recently, the outlet says, agents like Muse could still browse the site and pull listings.
How did Amazon handle Muse?
Amazon blocked Muse from shopping on Amazon.com in September, The Decoder and an analysis published by Search Engine Journal reported, citing GeekWire. Search Engine Journal says shoppers who sent Muse to Amazon on the night of Sept. 20 saw a notice saying that "continued access by an unauthorized AI agent violates Amazon's Conditions of Use." Amazon gave GeekWire three reasons, according to Search Engine Journal: Meta gave Amazon no notice before Muse began using its store, Muse does not identify itself when browsing, and it "appears to capture and store customer credentials."
Before the block, Meta had said that Muse cannot see users' passwords or payment details, The Decoder reports. Search Engine Journal said Meta had not responded to the block as of Sept. 22. Search Engine Journal notes that Meta's launch materials say credentials are kept in each user's own virtual machine rather than on central Meta systems, and that Amazon did not publish evidence for its credential claim. It also notes that Amazon runs shopping agents of its own. Amazon told GeekWire that its own Buy for Me agent identifies itself and lets brands opt out, and that third-party apps "should operate openly and respect service provider decisions about whether or not to participate," Search Engine Journal reports.
Are people actually shopping through agents?
The Verge describes a mixed picture across retailers. It says Amazon blocks outside agents from browsing and shopping, Target allows them to browse in some cases and blocks them in others, and Shopify has opened its catalog so shoppers can set up agents to buy for them.
The Verge also points to signs that few people shop this way so far. It reports that Uber said it completed only four rides through third-party agents in the third quarter, along with about 500 Uber Eats orders in Halloween week. DoorDash said it handled only "several hundred" orders placed by third-party agents; separately, it reported 993 million total orders last quarter, The Verge reports. These are the companies' figures as reported by The Verge.
Questions readers are asking
Has eBay confirmed that it blocked Meta's Muse?
No. According to The Verge, an eBay spokesperson declined to say directly whether the company recently set new limits, while saying eBay has restricted agent access in some cases.
Did Meta respond?
Meta declined to comment to The Verge on the eBay report. Before Amazon's block in September, Meta had said Muse cannot see passwords or payment details, according to The Decoder. Search Engine Journal said Meta had not responded to the block as of Sept. 22.
Why did Amazon block Muse?
According to Search Engine Journal, Amazon told GeekWire that Meta gave it no notice before Muse began using its store, that the agent does not identify itself when browsing, and that it seems to keep customer login details.
Do other retailers allow AI shopping agents?
The Verge says approaches differ: Amazon blocks outside agents, Target restricts them in some cases, and Shopify has opened its catalog to them.
Sources
- #ebay
- #meta-muse
- #ai-agents
- #agentic-commerce
- #ecommerce
- #amazon
Get the day's top AI & tech stories on WhatsApp: Follow the NextFish channel
Get stories like this every morning.
Related
Agents3 min
OpenAI launches ChatGPT Wallet so its dots agents can buy for users
The payment feature starts with US ChatGPT Pro subscribers. Users approve each purchase with a biometric check, and agents get a payment token, not the real card number.
Agents3 min
Google opens Antigravity's /teamwork agents, claims math and code results
Google Research says its multi-agent system helped prove a 2013 conjecture and port large codebases to Rust, and offers 10,000 academics free access. Results are Google's own.
AnalysisAgents3 min
How big shopping and travel sites now write rules for AI agents
eBay, Target, Booking, Delta and Shopify have all added terms about AI agents. NextFish compared their terms with archived copies to see what changed and when.
Big Tech2 min
Amazon weighs 'World Product Graph' to index nearly every product: Reuters
Reuters reports an internal Amazon plan to gather data on items sold anywhere, partly to counter AI shopping agents. Amazon says the draft may not reflect its plans.