Etsy says it will rewrite AI training terms as long-time sellers quit
New terms let Etsy and its partners use seller content to train AI. After long-time sellers left, Etsy said it would not train models to copy their work and promised new wording.
Key takeaways
- Etsy's new terms, due December 16, let it and its partners use seller content to train AI, a clause the old terms did not have.
- Several long-time sellers closed their shops in protest, The New York Times reported.
- Etsy says it does not train AI models designed to copy sellers' work and will send sellers revised terms.
- Etsy says it uses seller content for translations, marketing and seller tools, and shares it with fraud-detection and discovery partners.
- Some critics doubt Etsy's reassurance; PC Gamer's Tyler Wilde argued sellers should be left out of AI training by default.
Etsy says it will revise new terms of use that would let it train artificial intelligence on sellers' content, after several long-time sellers closed their shops in protest, The New York Times reported, according to TNW. Engadget also reported the seller exodus and Etsy's response.
The updated terms, due to take effect on December 16, say Etsy and its "third party partners and vendors" may use seller content to "develop, train, test and improve artificial intelligence and machine learning technologies," the outlets report. The earlier version of the terms had no clause on AI, the Times reported, according to TNW.
Why are sellers leaving?
In an Instagram post, illustrator Aaron Millard announced he would delete a shop he had kept for close to ten years and that sellers had no way to opt out, TNW reports. Kristen and Geoff Zephyrus, whose stationery and home goods shop has been on Etsy for 13 years, also shut it down. "For Etsy to be helping to train algorithms with our human content is just unimaginably awful," Kristen Zephyrus told the Times.
What does Etsy say?
In a post on Etsy's site, James Ossman, an Etsy vice president, said the company does not train AI models meant to copy sellers' work. "We do not use your content to train AI models designed to copy your original work or replace your creativity," he wrote, according to Engadget, adding that sellers' content belongs to them. Etsy said the new language only clarifies how it already uses AI on its marketplace, Engadget reports.
According to Engadget, Ossman said Etsy uses seller content to translate listings automatically, to promote listings in marketing campaigns and to train tools that help sellers improve listings and track their shops. He said Etsy's rules bar AI crawlers from collecting listings for model training, and that the third parties given access include fraud-detection services and partners that help buyers find items off Etsy. In a statement to the Times, he said revised terms would be sent to sellers soon, TNW reports.
Are critics convinced?
Not all of them. Tyler Wilde, PC Gamer's U.S. editor-in-chief, wrote that the clause looks like open-ended permission to use members' content for AI training of any kind and argued that sellers should be left out of AI training by default, TNW reports. Engadget notes that it is unclear whether the clarification will bring sellers back.
This is not the first seller revolt: TNW notes that over 20,000 sellers held a strike in 2022 after Etsy raised its fees.
Questions readers are asking
What did Etsy change in its terms?
It added a clause letting Etsy and its "third party partners and vendors" use seller content to "develop, train, test and improve artificial intelligence and machine learning technologies," effective December 16.
Will Etsy use sellers' work to train AI?
Etsy says it does not train AI models designed to copy sellers' original work, but it uses seller content for features such as translation and seller tools, according to Engadget.
Can sellers opt out?
Illustrator Aaron Millard said sellers had no way to opt out, TNW reports. Etsy has said it will send revised terms soon.
Sources
- #etsy
- #ai-training
- #terms-of-service
- #creators
- #data-rights
Get the day's top AI & tech stories on WhatsApp: Follow the NextFish channel
Get stories like this every morning.
Related
AI2 min
Google opens its Genie 4 world model to developers in the Gemini API
Developers can now generate playable 720p worlds with sound from a prompt or image, at about 10 cents per second of output, with sessions capped at two minutes.
AI2 min
OpenAI details its defenses against adversarial distillation
OpenAI says new safeguards cut attacks that pull hidden reasoning from GPT-6.2 Astra to under 1% success in its own tests, and that it acts against thousands of accounts a week.
AI2 min
Thinking Machines releases Inkling 2 Mini, a looped open-weights model
The 26.4B-parameter model runs its middle layers three times per token and needs about 20GB of memory, letting it run on laptops, the company says.
AI2 min
AI-made proof of Generalized Riemann Hypothesis compiles, awaits review
Anthropic's Levent Alpöge says its models produced the proof. Independent checkers say the code compiles, but Scott Aaronson expects understanding it to take years.