Italy fines Meta €805 million over Facebook's phone gallery access
The Garante says the Facebook app for Android accessed photos and videos on users' phones without specific consent. Meta has 60 days to change how the feature asks for permission.
Key takeaways
- Italy's Garante fined Meta Platforms Ireland €805 million over a Facebook for Android feature that suggests gallery photos and videos for posts.
- The regulator says gallery access came through one app-wide permission after a generic prompt, and the feature was on by default.
- It acted under ePrivacy rules and rejected Meta's argument that Ireland's regulator should handle the case.
- Meta has 60 days to add a dedicated consent request and leave the feature off unless users opt in, including those who allowed access before.
- The inquiry did not look at AI training, which Meta denies; a 2026 cloud processing feature may be examined separately.
The Garante, Italy's privacy watchdog, has imposed an €805 million penalty on Meta Platforms Ireland. It says Facebook's Android app accessed the photo galleries of Italian users, including pictures, videos and their metadata, without asking for consent specific to that purpose or telling people clearly what was happening. The regulator announced the decision on Nov. 14.
The case concerns a Facebook feature that, while people scroll, suggests photos and videos from their phone's gallery as ideas for posts. The Garante says the feature has been available since 2023. Its investigation began in July 2025 after a complaint from the Bolzano consumer group Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti and included a technical analysis by the authority, according to its statement and Italian news reports.
What did the regulator find?
According to the Garante, Facebook asked for gallery access through a single permission that covered the whole app and several features with different needs. That request came after a generic prompt to "enable other features," which did not let users understand that they were also turning on gallery suggestions. The feature was also switched on by default, the regulator said.
The Garante added that a permission of this kind, if granted in full, gives the app ongoing access to every photo on the phone, and neither the user nor the regulator can see which of those images Meta actually uses.
Why did Italy act instead of Ireland?
Meta's main EU base is in Ireland, and under the GDPR the Irish regulator normally leads cases against it. Meta argued that the matter belonged there. The Garante rejected that argument because it applied ePrivacy rules, which do not have the GDPR's one-stop-shop system, The Next Web and the Garante's statement report. The Garante said Article 122 of the Italian privacy code, which transposes the EU ePrivacy directive, protects a phone as part of its owner's private sphere. In its view, any access to what is stored on it therefore requires free and informed consent, even if nothing is transmitted and no harm results.
How was the fine set?
The regulator said it weighed the number of people affected, about 20 million Android users in Italy, and the length of the violation, which it says is still continuing for users who have not updated the app and for those who already granted the permission. It also considered a 2019 decision against the company and what it called poor cooperation during the investigation. Changes Meta made after the complaint counted in the company's favour, but the Garante judged them to have come too late and to reach only people who install the update.
The Garante said the fine equals just under half of one percent of the group's worldwide turnover.
What does Meta have to do now?
Meta has 60 days to introduce a dedicated consent request for the feature, spell out the feature's purpose, make clear that it reads the gallery and show how to turn it off, and leave it switched off unless a user opts in, including people who had already allowed gallery access, the regulator said. If Meta does not comply in time, the feature cannot be turned on for users without valid consent. The company must report its first steps to the Garante within 30 days and the measures it has taken within 90 days.
What did the case not cover?
The Garante said its inquiry did not look into any use of gallery content for training artificial intelligence, something Meta denies. The regulator said it may look separately at a newer feature, launched in 2026, that processes gallery content in the cloud.
Meta was not immediately available for comment, Reuters reported, according to The Next Web. NextFish found no public response from the company when this was written. The sources do not say whether Meta will appeal.
Questions readers are asking
Why was Meta fined in Italy?
The Garante says Facebook's Android app accessed pictures, videos and metadata stored on phones for a gallery suggestions feature, without consent specific to that purpose or clear information.
Why didn't Ireland's regulator handle the case?
The Garante applied ePrivacy rules, which do not use the GDPR's one-stop-shop system, so it rejected Meta's argument that the case belonged in Ireland.
What must Meta change?
It has 60 days to add a dedicated consent request, explain the feature clearly and leave it switched off unless users opt in, including those who had already allowed gallery access.
Was the case about AI training?
No. The Garante said its inquiry did not look into any use of gallery content for AI training, which Meta denies. A newer cloud processing feature may be examined separately.
Sources
- Garante per la protezione dei dati personali: Facebook: il Garante privacy sanziona Meta per 805 milioni di euro
- The Next Web: Italy fines Meta €805m over Facebook's access to Android photos
- Sky TG24: Garante: 805 milioni di multa a Meta per uso di foto su Fb senza consenso
- Il Messaggero: Meta, multa da 805 milioni: accesso a foto e video degli utenti senza consenso
- Today.it: Multa da 805 milioni a Meta dal Garante della privacy
- #meta
- #privacy
- #eprivacy
- #italy
- #regulation
Get the day's top AI & tech stories on WhatsApp: Follow the NextFish channel
Get stories like this every morning.
Related
Data Centers & Energy3 min
Malaysia to require data centres to disclose power use and GPU imports
Trade minister Johari Abdul Ghani says the rule will be written into law so the government can monitor data centres. He also said some imported GPUs had been re-exported.
Big Tech2 min
Amazon weighs 'World Product Graph' to index nearly every product: Reuters
Reuters reports an internal Amazon plan to gather data on items sold anywhere, partly to counter AI shopping agents. Amazon says the draft may not reflect its plans.
Big Tech2 min
Google lets Gemini read Google Wallet data to answer money questions
Google is rolling out a Wallet connection for US Gemini users, and optionally bank and card accounts via Plaid, for budgeting help. Google says access is read-only and opt-in.
Big Tech3 min
Google DeepMind staff ask UK arbitration body to force union ballot
Two unions filed with the Central Arbitration Committee, WIRED reports, seeking a ballot for about 1,000 UK staff. Google DeepMind says it has acted in good faith.