UK tribunal confirms government served Apple with encryption notice
The tribunal said the Home Office cannot keep relying on 'neither confirm nor deny' in this case. It has not ruled on whether the notice is lawful.
Key takeaways
- The Investigatory Powers Tribunal confirmed the UK government served Apple with a technical capability notice.
- It rejected the government's reliance on its 'neither confirm nor deny' policy in this case, Reuters reports.
- A first notice was dropped after US talks; a second, issued in July, covers only Apple's UK customers, Reuters says.
- The government argued confirmation would help hostile actors; the ruling does not decide whether the notice is lawful.
- A full hearing is expected in the first half of 2027.
The British government has issued Apple with a technical capability notice, an order that can be used to get around encryption protecting customer data, the Investigatory Powers Tribunal confirmed on Thursday, according to Reuters and Recorded Future News. The ruling means the government can no longer rely on its policy to "neither confirm nor deny" the notice in these proceedings.
The tribunal's three judges stated that the government "has given Apple a technical capability notice," Recorded Future News reports. According to Reuters, the tribunal found the government had failed to show that acknowledging the notice in these proceedings would harm national security. With so much information already public, confirming the notice would do little, if any, damage, the tribunal found, according to Reuters.
The government's lawyer had argued that dropping the policy posed a national security risk and would help hostile actors, Reuters reports. Neither the British government nor Apple commented immediately, Reuters reports.
What is the dispute about?
The case centers on Apple's Advanced Data Protection (ADP) feature, Recorded Future News reports. ADP keeps encryption keys on users' own devices rather than on Apple's servers, so Apple cannot read the content of iCloud accounts even when it receives a lawful request.
Britain issued a first notice in January last year seeking access to encrypted cloud backups of both US and British users, Reuters reports. That demand was dropped after months of negotiations with the Trump administration, and in July Britain issued a second notice that covers only Apple's UK customers, according to Reuters. Apple withdrew ADP for British users after the earlier notice, following reports in February 2025, Digital Watch and Recorded Future News report.
Apple has brought a renewed challenge at the tribunal but has been unable to explain publicly why because of legal restrictions, Reuters says. Under the Investigatory Powers Act 2016, such notices can require an operator to keep the ability to help authorities, including, under specified conditions, removing encryption it applied, Digital Watch explains.
Why did the tribunal reject secrecy?
Lawyers for Privacy International and Liberty argued that the refusal no longer made sense, since US politicians and officials had spoken publicly about the first order and anonymous UK government sources had confirmed it, Reuters reports. The tribunal agreed, citing reports in The Times and the Financial Times that it said seemed to stem from officials briefing journalists in private, according to Reuters.
In an April 2025 judgment, the tribunal had already cited remarks from senior US politicians, among them President Donald Trump, which seemed to show the notice existed, Recorded Future News reports.
The government has defended its silence before. Earlier this year, Security Minister Dan Jarvis told Parliament that not commenting was "a long-standing position held by successive Governments for obvious reasons of national security," Recorded Future News reports. Liberty welcomed Thursday's ruling as a win for transparency, Reuters says.
What happens next?
The ruling does not decide whether the notice to Apple is lawful, and its contents remain secret, Recorded Future News and Digital Watch report. A substantive hearing is scheduled for the first half of 2027, according to Recorded Future News. The tribunal also issued private judgments that could not be disclosed, and said whether any details of the notice can be revealed will be dealt with later, Reuters reports.
The ruling came on complaints by Privacy International, Liberty and two individuals, which also challenge the lawfulness and secrecy of the wider notice regime, Digital Watch reports. The Digital Watch article was written by a Privacy International staff member.
Questions readers are asking
What is a technical capability notice?
An order under the Investigatory Powers Act 2016 that can require an operator to keep the ability to help authorities, including, under specified conditions, removing encryption it applied, Digital Watch explains.
Did the tribunal say the notice was illegal?
No. It only ruled that the government cannot keep refusing to confirm the notice exists in these proceedings. Its lawfulness will be considered at a later hearing.
What did Apple do after the first notice?
It withdrew Advanced Data Protection, its end-to-end encryption option for iCloud, for users in Britain, and it has challenged the government at the tribunal.
Sources
- Reuters via MarketScreener: UK tribunal confirms government order demanding access to Apple data
- Recorded Future News: UK court confirms British government served Apple with secret encryption notice
- Digital Watch: UK tribunal orders government to confirm existence of secret technical capability notice issued to Apple
- #apple
- #encryption
- #uk
- #investigatory-powers
- #privacy
Get the day's top AI & tech stories on WhatsApp: Follow the NextFish channel
Get stories like this every morning.
Related
Policy & Safety3 min
Oregon sues OpenAI for $2 billion, alleging ChatGPT endangers children
The state's attorney general says OpenAI misled parents about ChatGPT's safety for minors. OpenAI points to its parental controls and other safeguards.
Policy & Safety3 min
California sues OpenAI over Hugging Face hack and AI agent safety
Rob Bonta says OpenAI tested dangerous models without proper oversight. OpenAI says the suit appears to single it out over a challenge all major AI labs have identified.
Policy & Safety3 min
US and nine partners sign Pax Silica pledge to protect AI supply chains
The San Francisco Declaration defines the kinds of technology and infrastructure to protect and proposes five working groups. Outlets differ on whether nine or ten signed.
Policy & Safety3 min
Duffy ties FAA ground stop to contractor's copper-to-fiber work
The transportation secretary says a router flooded the air traffic network after L3Harris upgraded a remote site. Officials have not yet found the root cause.