UN talks on 'killer robots' end without treaty talks, push work to 2028
Countries in Geneva agreed to keep working on lethal autonomous weapons for two years, without a mandate for a legally binding treaty. NGOs called it disappointing.
Key takeaways
- U.N. talks in Geneva on lethal autonomous weapons ended without a mandate to negotiate a binding treaty, Politico Europe reports.
- The 128 member countries of the weapons convention agreed to work on an instrument over two years, reporting to a 2028 meeting.
- Russia blocked formal negotiations, and two EU diplomats named six other countries, including the U.S. and U.K., as also resisting binding rules.
- The Red Cross had urged binding rules within a year; Human Rights Watch called the outcome disappointing.
- The sources include no responses from the countries said to have resisted.
U.N. talks on rules for autonomous weapons, often called "killer robots," ended in Geneva on Saturday without a mandate to negotiate a legally binding treaty, Politico Europe reports. Countries instead agreed to keep working on the issue for two more years, with conclusions due at a meeting in 2028.
States that are party to the U.N. Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons spent five days trying to agree on binding rules for weapons that can choose and strike targets without human approval, according to Politico. The convention's 128 member countries settled on "the elaboration of an international instrument on lethal autonomous weapons systems" over two years, according to Julien Thöni, the Swiss diplomat chairing the talks. The Verge says countries agreed to "start discussing options," and, citing NPR, that room was left for some future rules to remain "optional."
Who resisted binding rules?
Because decisions need consensus, Russia managed to block formal negotiations throughout the week, Politico reports, and it refused to let observers such as the European Union take part, so talks were held informally. Two EU diplomats told Politico that Israel, Turkey, Japan, South Korea, the U.K. and the U.S. also resisted a binding regulation. According to NPR, as cited by The Verge, Russia objected to the agenda on day one, and the U.S. suggested five years of discussion on guidelines that would be optional and nonbinding. "You can blame Russia, but they are not the only ones," a Brazilian diplomat told Politico. The sources do not include responses from the countries named.
France proposed a hybrid text mixing binding and non-binding elements, while Germany argued for an international instrument rather than a legally binding protocol, Politico reports. Late in the talks, countries that wanted regulation, among them Austria, Belgium, Brazil and Ireland, weakened their demands because they feared going home with nothing, the Brazilian diplomat said.
Why do campaigners say it is urgent?
Before the talks, the International Committee of the Red Cross said legally binding rules should be drafted within a year, a call backed by the U.N. secretary-general and Pope Leo, NPR reported according to The Verge. Ukraine, Russia, Israel and others use drones and robots in war while saying humans keep final control over firing, Politico notes. Stop Killer Robots, a coalition of more than 300 organizations, says autonomous systems have already been tested or used, including in Ukraine and Gaza.
"This outcome is disappointing," Human Rights Watch's Verity Coyle said, according to Politico. Rain Liivoja of the Asia-Pacific Institute for Law and Security said, according to Politico, that with no mention of a binding instrument in the decision, "it remains possible — likely, even — that there will be no treaty by the end of 2028."
A group of intergovernmental experts is to report its conclusions to a 2028 meeting of the treaty's member countries, according to the final decision seen by Politico.
Questions readers are asking
What did the UN talks on killer robots agree?
To work over the next two years on an international instrument on lethal autonomous weapons, with experts reporting to a 2028 meeting, but without a mandate to negotiate a binding treaty.
Which countries opposed binding rules?
Russia blocked formal negotiations, Politico reports, and two EU diplomats named Israel, Turkey, Japan, South Korea, the U.K. and the U.S. as also resisting. The sources carry no responses from those countries.
What are lethal autonomous weapons?
Politico describes them as weapons able to pick and strike targets with no human approval.
Sources
- #autonomous-weapons
- #united-nations
- #killer-robots
- #ai-regulation
- #geneva
Get the day's top AI & tech stories on WhatsApp: Follow the NextFish channel
Get stories like this every morning.
Related
Policy & Safety2 min
Pentagon CIO Kirsten Davies named acting US cyber director
Trump said Friday he fired Sean Cairncross because he was not 'good enough'; other officials had described a resignation. The change follows a series of US tech outages.
Policy & Safety2 min
House report warns US firms against building on Chinese open-weight AI
The report names Airbnb, DoorDash and Cursor maker Anysphere as users. Cursor told lawmakers it may phase out Chinese-developed models over geopolitical risk.
Policy & Safety3 min
UK tribunal confirms government served Apple with encryption notice
The tribunal said the Home Office cannot keep relying on 'neither confirm nor deny' in this case. It has not ruled on whether the notice is lawful.
AI4 min
Study: top AI models can be tricked into marking civilians as targets
Vals says models from Anthropic, OpenAI, Google and others flagged civilians in drone images and dropped refusals when told it was a game. Anthropic and OpenAI promise safeguards.